(based on 49 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 49 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
By Prize-winning baker
from Woodland Park, CO
About Me Avid Cook
Comments about Mrs Andersons™ Piecrust Shield:
I LOVE these. I have some of my own and now give them as gifts.
Bottom LineYes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Mrs.Anderson's Piecrust Shield
When I ordered only one was available and I will order more for myself and friends. Great to use and I was very pleased about my Home-made crusts.
By Lin, the "from scratch" pie maker
from Montgomery, Texas
Had to arrange my pie crust edge straight up rather than over the rim in order to fit the metal ring on the edge of the pie plate. Worked very well in a convection oven. The next time I bake a pie, I will try using the pie shield in a regular oven
Great pie cover
By The Teach
Great addition to my kitchen!
By Catie the cook
from Omaha, NE
About Me Casual Cook
The large shields do not fit over the crust in a 10 inch pie pan. They are a great idea, but do not work on a large pan. It was very disappointing to me.
Bottom LineNo, I would not recommend this to a friend
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
Greatest idea ever!
By Maggie the entertainer!
from Newton, Iowa
This is the greatest invention! In the past, I would fold aluminum foil and crunch it on the crust edge so it would not burn or over bake. For my relatives whom bake lots of pies, I give as gifts and they tell me they use them every time for pie baking as I do. I use the larger size much more than the smaller. I do wish they had a smaller size for individual pies.
Used Once and Works Great
from Vicihy, Missouri
I couldn't find any thing that wasn't great. It's much more sturdy than the foil type and stays in place. I love it!
Mrs Andersons™ Piecrust Shield
from Pine Bluff, Arkansas
The edges of a pie always gets done before the top of the crust, this piecrust shield really helps both the edges & top to brown together.
I love it! Its easy to use.
from Marquette, MI
I love that its simple to use. It just drops over my pie, and it does the job. So much easier than aluminum foil.
from Lake Charles, Louisiana
The sturdiness of these piecrust shield are really great. Ones I had previously were very flimsy but these will be used over and over for years to come. Having them in 2 different sizes will be useful, also.